Nuggets of Truth in Samantha Brick’s ‘Don’t Hate Me Because I’m Beautiful’ Piece
Many have gotten their knickers in a bunch over journalist Samantha Brick’s piece about the downsides of being a pretty girl. Namely, she says other women are mean to her because they’re jealous.
Naturally, this has sparked a firestorm of criticism, mostly aimed at if she’s hot or not. Some of the comments are down right ugly. But she touches on something that I’ve seen happen.
Sure there’s plenty of upsides to being pretty. It can make it easier to get past the velvet ropes life offers, but like everything there can be challenges. For example, some attractive women have a hard time being taken seriously by male co-workers unless they present the (and I hate to use the term) bitchy exterior.
I certainly don’t have the problem that Brick says she has due to her looks. I’m just your average brown-skinned girl, but I have a friend who is drop dead gorgeous. Stunning. Well, I’ve got a lot of them, but this one is particularly striking and she too has had problems with women.
I remember the first time she told me: “I have no girl friends.” I was surprised because she’s shoot-the-milk-out-your-nose funny, fiercely loyal and honest. But I gave her a good once over, her perfectly petite, yet curvy frame, glowing olive skin, thick healthy mane, piercingly green eyes, yaddayaddayadda you get the idea. I responded: I bet so.
This speaks to the point I think Brick was trying to make in her essay, one that was lost in its arrogant tone. We all know about Mean Girls and each of us has some mean in us, and for some that can really come out when a beautiful woman is involved.
Admit it, we’ve all done and/or thought it. Our friend with the perfect body, we say: “Ugh I hate her.” The same goes for the girl with the amazingly awesome hair, or the chic with age-appropriate but trendy clothes and the mom who’s the total package and always put together. Our comments are said playfully, but there is a spark of jealousy.
It’s too bad really, we all need to do a better job of being supportive. Present company included. I remember not too long ago though, Hubby and I were sitting at a bar after my Listen To Your Mother audition. There was a woman with wild tresses and a gorgeous face to match.
Hubby and I had trouble not staring at her, finally, after a few glasses of wine, I decided to pay the stranger a compliment. Walking up to her, I got nervous. I’d never done this before, not even to a guy that I liked. I took a deep breath:
“Excuse me, I just wanted to say, platonically speaking, you are so gorgeous.”
She quickly flashed me her million dollar smile. “Thanks, that means a lot.”
“Sure!” OK, I thought. I’ve said it, now how to exit gracefully…
“No really, thanks because I’ve been having a tough time at things, so that really brightens my week. Thank you.”
“You’re welcome.” I smiled back, wished her a good evening and returned to my husband.
It felt good to be nice to a pretty lady, it was much better than being a mean girl.
I feel we should all pay each other compliments more often. That woman who’s really overweight but has fabulous shoes. The amazing way a mother is handling her kids. The laughter that a person can bring from being constantly funny. We need to let people know how awesome they are.
Hey! Thanks for the comment, I am embarrassed to see how long it’s taken me to reply. :s But you’re right we do need to pay compliments to people more often (and to ourselves too!) I think just being more positive begets more positivity. Speaking of which, I’ve always felt that you’ve got awesome hair and an awesome smile. 🙂
Agreed. I haven’t read her piece yet, but if it’s arrogant then you’re right, that’s too bad. Because there is a point to be made and we would be better off without all the crazy competitiveness. Honestly, can you imagine how powerful women would be if we started joining forces more often?
Here here Jess! If we could all get in one accord then how many wars would wane, how many more mouths fed, babies clothed, etc. I guess that’s why it’s important to support each other even with the small stuff. 🙂
I think you made her point in a much friendlier and positive way.
Thanks! I try to be positive, but admittedly it can be hard. With this piece and whether this chic is hot and what she faces… I think the arrogance is ugly.
Well said! I have had some extra beautiful friends who I have seen be very judged, in a bad way, for their looks. On the other hand, I can relate…I was just today chatting with my son’s preschool teacher whom I have become friends with and I said how thin she was seeming lately…you look like you’re 98 pounds I said. Oh no! She said as if I was way off, I’m 106. I think the last time I weighed 106 was in the 4th grade and since there is no way I will EVER be one of those petite girls I did feel a bit jealous…
I think my booty weighs 98 pounds. I understand being jealous of weight, trust me, I do it all the time. I just think it’s important that we don’t let that negative attitude affect our behavior toward others *or* ourselves. And you are simply stunning, I love going through your FB pictures, like the scary stalker that I am, because I enjoy seeing the little girl that was my friend in school and the beautiful woman she’s become all wrapped into one image.
I’m afraid I’m pretty suspicious of women who blame not having girlfriends on being too beautiful. Perhaps they are not looking for the right types of friends, but I think often something more must be at play.
One of my best friends is gorgeous — hair, eyes, smile, body — she’s the whole package. Back in our bar-hopping days, guys used to hit on her all the time, sometimes saying she looked like Sheryl Crow. But in addition to the looks, she also has an amazing heart — she’s generous, empathetic and warm — and smart and funny, too! And she has countless girlfriends.
Thanks for sharing this story. I hadn’t read about it, and it certainly got me thinking!
You know when I read this comment, I thought that you were talking about me until you mentioned your bar-hopping days. Kidding!!! You’re right in that there are some gorgeous girls who have such a great personality that people flock to them like moths to a flame. I just wish Samantha Brick had expressed her point in a less ugly manner.
I don’t know if it’s just this photo but Samantha Brick isn’t that pretty. I contend that you, Melanie, are prettier than Ms. Brick. Therefore, I suggest Samantha Brick’s problem with other women being mean is her own personality. Just my opinion, without any true evidence…
My bias with coworkers has nothing to do with looks, age, race, or even personality. I have trouble taking someone seriously if they can’t stand behind their claims or display a lack of intellect.
Actually, a lazy intellect is more accurate rather than lacking. Everyone has the potential for great ideas but few really try hard; a mind is a terrible thing to waste. Therefore, it’s hard to take someone seriously when they don’t even make a half-hearted attempt.
Well, well Ron thanks for the compliment! You’re right it is hard to take people seriously when the insincerity is there. I can only imagine how the mood in the office changed for her after that piece was published. Thanks for stopping by and commenting!! Happy to have you here. 🙂
Bravo! How wonderful would this world be if we were actually kind to each other and gave compliments without hesitation. Being older, this comes so much easier. As a youngin, I just didn’t have the confidence or the love for myself necessary to always be kind ~ sad. Maybe it’s true that wisdom comes with age. Now, I get such a kick out of giving compliments, because truth is, we all want and need to hear that we’re pretty or a good mom or writer or whatever. Share the love!
Yes!!! Let’s share the love. I agree it’s easier to be complimentary when you’re more secure with yourself and generally, *generally* you’re more secure with yourself as you get older, have a few failures and successes under your belt. Thanks for your comment!!
Interesting post! And I have a little something in the way of very un-scientific research to add. . . I’m a natural blond and never did anything to my hair until my early thirties, when I finally gave in to my lifelong desire to be a redhead. I immediately noticed that men paid less attention to me (which was fine) and that women were more welcoming and friendlier. That continued as long as I kept my hair red. . .then after a year or so of shelling out too much money to my stylist, I went back to the regular me and the dynamic switched back to what I had always known. Just my (weird) two cents!
Even though your two cents are unscientific (they’re not weird though! Not at all!!) it strikes at the core of what I am trying to show. It’s that there’s this unnecessary female jealousy that we really should nip in the bud. Now, clearly you’re a nice person who isn’t arrogant unlike Samantha Brick, so I’m sure you’ve got plenty of girlfriends. I think her attitude has more to do with getting rebuffed than her looks. Thanks for stopping by!